Families for Palestine appreciates the concern expressed in the joint statement regarding Israel’s military operation in Rafah, and the call for a humanitarian ceasefire. We find the statement, however, does not go far enough when it comes to addressing crucial aspects of the ongoing genocide in Palestine.

Lack of strong diplomatic action

The characterisation of Israel as a ‘friend’ without a clear condemnation of its actions is deeply troubling. Failure to address the genocide undermines the severity of the situation and fails to hold Israel accountable for its actions. The statement expresses concern and calls for an immediate humanitarian ceasefire, but it does not outline any concrete steps or diplomatic actions the three countries are willing to take to pressure Israel into compliance. As such, we express profound disappointment in the statement’s lack of strong diplomatic pressure. 

Unequal emphasis on ceasefire obligations

It is crucial to recognise Palestine’s legal right to self-defence within the framework of international law. The statement’s failure to acknowledge this right undermines the principles of justice and equality. Furthermore, the disproportionate impact on civilians, particularly with over 40% of casualties being children, cannot be overlooked. The statement’s illusion of equanimity between the two parties creates a misleading narrative.

Unclear consequences for violations

The statement does not outline specific consequences or actions that would be taken if Israel does not heed the call for a ceasefire. Without clear repercussions, the statement does not serve as an effective deterrent. In addition to calling for a ceasefire, we stress the need for exemplary economic sanctions against Netanyahu and all those responsible for the genocide. This is imperative to send a powerful message about accountability for war crimes and crimes against humanity.

Limited mention of root causes

The statement touches on the need for a negotiated political solution and a two-state solution, but it does not delve into the root causes of the conflict or address longstanding issues such as settlements, the blockade, or the status of Jerusalem. 

Failure to acknowledge Australia’s role

There is no acknowledgement of the severe impact of Australia’s own decision to cut off UNRWA funding, despite the lack of sufficient evidence to support its decision. The government’s own actions in this regard are exacerbating an already desperate situation, implicating Australia in the forced starvation of the Palestinian population – a criminal act under article 2 of the Genocide Convention. Similarly, Australia’s continued military exports to Israel, with 50 approved this year alone, is not acknowledged. We urgently call for a re-evaluation of these decisions.

***

In conclusion, Families for Palestine urges the Prime Ministers to reconsider and strengthen your commitment to justice, accountability, and the protection of human rights. We remain vigilant in our efforts to bring attention to these critical issues, calling on all governments to take decisive action to end the genocide of the Palestinian people.